SimplyScripts Discussion Board
Blog Home - Produced Movie Script Library - TV Scripts - Unproduced Scripts - Contact - Site Map
ScriptSearch
Welcome, Guest.
It is March 28th, 2024, 7:32pm
Please login or register.
Was Portal Recent Posts Home Help Calendar Search Register Login
Please do read the guidelines that govern behavior on the discussion board. It will make for a much more pleasant experience for everyone. A word about SimplyScripts and Censorship


Produced Script Database (Updated!)
One Week Challenge - Who Wrote What and Writers' Choice.


Scripts studios are posting for award consideration

Short Script of the Day | Featured Script of the Month | Featured Short Scripts Available for Production
Submit Your Script

How do I get my film's link and banner here?
All screenplays on the simplyscripts.com and simplyscripts.net domain are copyrighted to their respective authors. All rights reserved. This screenplaymay not be used or reproduced for any purpose including educational purposes without the expressed written permission of the author.
Forum Login
Username: Create a new Account
Password:     Forgot Password

SimplyScripts Screenwriting Discussion Board    One Week Challenge    January 2014 - One Week Challenge  ›  Constant Escapement - OWC Moderators: Mr. Blonde, dabrast
Users Browsing Forum
No Members and 1 Guests

 Pages: « 1, 2, 3 » : All
Recommend Print
  Author    Constant Escapement - OWC  (currently 6555 views)
c m hall
Posted: January 18th, 2014, 10:54am Report to Moderator
New



Location
peninsula of Jersey
Posts
422
Posts Per Day
0.08
This was a wild ride, but very enjoyable.  The things that happened in the story were less interesting to me than how they happened.  I admire the vivid imagery and the crispness of the moments in time selected for juxtaposition -- this could be an entertaining and successful film if the director followed the visual cues and energy of the script.
Logged Offline
Private Message Reply: 15 - 30
PrussianMosby
Posted: January 19th, 2014, 1:39pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Posts
1399
Posts Per Day
0.37
First 5 and I was excited. Sadly it falls apart from that point.

I missed the believability. Politician's careers are finished with a death bringing accident, especially with children.
Ok. I swallow the pill. I get more and more the drama flair, the funeral is been planed and everything. This depth enlarged more and more the question:

Why has Eric a time machine? Just, because he's a professor?

That works in comedy or sci fi short. I would accept it. It's too haphazardly presented.

Then Eric travels back in 13 century to kill an ancestor of the politician to erase the whole family. Maybe, because of your hint the politician's republican's family brought just dead to the world.  "Feels" biased.

It all jumps around in a drama of a time traveler, from who I don't know why he can do it; after an accident where the guilt of the bad guy wasn't shown. Things just happen on the surface without the needed believability.

It's the best title of the OWC for me, but didn't represent the script's content.

The positive is that it was a good read until I started to ask myself all these questions.



Logged
Private Message Reply: 16 - 30
SteveUK
Posted: January 20th, 2014, 10:57am Report to Moderator
New



Location
UK
Posts
201
Posts Per Day
0.04
This was a bit mixed for me - parts are extremely well written (a few missing commas aside), especially the characters - they seemed both believable and real, and I was drawn into their world. But you have a tendency to overwrite some descriptions. Maybe this is just a personal preference, but I found that it bogged the story down quite a bit.

I found the opening really intriguing, and it kept me wanting to turn the page to find out what was happening. Unfortunately the story then became a little dull as it went on and I started to lose interest.

Eric's constant talking to himself didn't help - it always takes me out of a story when a character seems to be constantly having a conversation with himself. I'd try to cut as much of this out as you can if I were you.

I wasn't sure how the time travelling coffin actually worked. i could understand it being able to go back in time from his basement as it was rigged up to the machine, but there was no explanation as to how it was able to travel back into the present - he just gets inside and it vanishes. At least show him doing something when he gets back inside it to operate the machine.

I also didn't like the sequence of him not being able to find the coffin, searching for it, then tripping over it - it felt a little pointless.

As for the ending, it was a bit of an anti-climax and just felt a little flat. I was kinda left wanting more. Good effort though, you clearly have talent.
Logged Offline
Private Message Reply: 17 - 30
DV44
Posted: January 20th, 2014, 5:46pm Report to Moderator
Been Around



Location
California
Posts
510
Posts Per Day
0.12
Enjoyable read. Nicely written, yet a bit overly descriptive in some areas but I feel it worked here. I loved the concept of a man (Eric) traveling in time to save his son from a drunken driver. Interesting take having Eric wipe out Abe's ancestors so in return he wouldn't have been born but the ending had me bit confused. So Eric is now married to a different woman? How does that tie in with killing Abe's ancestors?

Overall, I like it. Just a little confused is all.

Congrats on completing the OWC.
Logged Offline
Private Message Reply: 18 - 30
RJ
Posted: January 22nd, 2014, 11:36pm Report to Moderator
New



Location
Australia
Posts
275
Posts Per Day
0.06
Although the description were a little dense (I agree with Steve - I like the leaner approach) I did like the idea in this one.

I liked the setup of the world before and how everything turned out.

I liked the 'homemade time machine'. I can see a lot of effort went into describing this - more so than most others, so kudos on that.

But, even though I did like this, I found myself wanting to know more - there was a lot left out and I think this would read better as a feature. I could see this as something I'd go to watch at the cinema. There are so many more angles on things that you could expand on. And I think that's my main quibble with this - things need to be explained more.

I also was feeling that the part after Eric had gone back, then he was just kind of mopping around was a tad long.  

The twist at the end was good.

As I said - turn this into a feature and I'll be there.

Good job.

Renee  
Logged
Private Message Reply: 19 - 30
LC
Posted: January 23rd, 2014, 1:08am Report to Moderator
Administrator



Location
The Great Southern Land
Posts
7581
Posts Per Day
1.34
I missed commenting on most of these entries, cause of work. I read quite a few however, and this was one I thought stood out. Not surprised now to see who wrote it - good to see you back on the boards, Re! Your wit and writing has been sorely missed

I think this could have been a contender.  It was very nicely written. Biggest problem I see with it is that I just don't think the payoff was satisfying enough for most readers.

If you'd ramped up the emotional/accident scene (sometimes less is more, I know... but not here imh), pulled at the heart strings a little more re the son's death, lost a little of the flab/self reflection of the character in the middle, and given us a stunner ending i.e., that the (new) woman who appears turns up with a different kid i.e., Eric has an entirely different life with a wife and child he's never met, then I think that would have been a cracker ending.

As usual you know what you're doing with the writing and the general consensus reflects this, I just think most readers felt a little shortchanged with the denouement... least I did.

Great work though.  


Logged
Private Message Reply: 20 - 30
rendevous
Posted: January 23rd, 2014, 8:49pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Away

Location
Over there.
Posts
2354
Posts Per Day
0.43
Now that I've been outed, er no, not like that. Not that there's anything wrong with that type of... Hang on, I'll start again.

Now that I've been named (that's better) I'll respond to a few points until you, or I, or perhaps both us, get bored and let it lie.

Firstly - Dustin Bowcott

Thanks for the kind comments at the start. As for the cereal bowl bit, I thought if I didn't mention the bowl then some smartarses, or perphaps dumbarses, would say hey, why is the guy eating cereal without a bowl? They'd have a image of him eating it straight out of the box or even eating barley straight from the field.
Erm, I think I've gone on quite enough about that now.


Quoted from DustinBowcott
Just leave it at 'types and clicks furiously'. He couldn't type with a keyboard, well he probably could, but it wouldn't be easy. One types using or on a keyboard.


What? He can type on a keyboard. Presumably you mean mouse. I put it as is because I hate it in movies when a character is typing furiously away on a keyboard yet the monitor shows them flicking through menus and selecting stuff. Nobody's shortcut skills are that good. Maybe I shouldn't settle pet peeves in a script.


Quoted from DustinBowcott
I think you could cut the second 'all about it' from this dialogue. Maybe write, tell the dog instead. or just leave it at, tell the dog.


Yeah, I could. But then she said it like that for comic effect. Which I found quite funny. I maybe alone in that finding. This has happened before.

And may occur again.


Quoted from DustinBowcott
What type of gun fits in a suit jacket? Is it a derringer? Do you mean for me to be imagining a pocket gun, or did you intend for something bigger? The thing is, one wouldn't attempt to tuck a derringer into the back of their pants, I'd imagine..


Well, it depends on the jacket. He may have deep pockets or even just a hole in the lining. It maybe his special 'gun with silencer pocket' jacket that he keeps near his yoyo.

I'd say it's not that big of a stretch to go with it. He's not trying to fit a rocket launcher in the back pocket of his jeans or an AK47 down his sock.


Quoted from DustinBowcott
In the above sequence it suddenly struck me that the coffin wouldn't be able to get back. I hope this is explained later..


I too have been suddenly struck. It was a few years ago and I was on the wrong side of town and...oh, wrong website.

Why wouldn't the coffin be able to get back? Jumping in time is alright but using a coffin shaped device to return isn't?

The idea was that he can get back home in the coffin shaped device by pressing a recall button. I didn't show it or state it as you don't get to see inside the coffin. His return journey is set up before he gets in the time machine to leave home.

I'm not sure why 'aquaintainted?' makes the guy sound stupid. No, it's not deliberate. Not sure what you had in mind.


Quoted from DustinBowcott
I'm not sure he letting go of a whoop is the right way to go about it. He lets out a whoop, would read better.


Not to do what I was trying to do. Never let out a whoop, or something similar, that came out a bit too loud and you're trying to avoid attention?


Quoted from DustinBowcott
Nice little story. Pretty basic... but too long. Well told for the most part. I get that they wanted their kid back and he ends up making things worse... or better. Who knows, his new chick may be freaky


Thanks for the compliments. Basic? Perhaps. I was going for satisfying. Judging from later comments I didn't quite manage it. Or didn't get even close, depending on who you ask.

I didn't think 15 pages was enough to get into a complicated or convoluted story. Too long? Maybe. It could do with trimming and polishing. There ain't many scripts or films that wouldn't benefit from a good going over with the scissors.

More later. Maybe...


Out Of Character - updated


New Used Car

Green

Right Back

The Deuce - OWC - now on STS

Other scripts here
Logged
Site Private Message Reply: 21 - 30
rendevous
Posted: January 23rd, 2014, 9:25pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Away

Location
Over there.
Posts
2354
Posts Per Day
0.43
Next up, Dreamscale.


Quoted from Dreamscale
But, on the negative side, too much detail that is meaningless.  I think this story as told could easily be done in 12 pages, meaning, as written, this drags unnecessarily, even though it is well done and well put together.


Detail that's meant to help set the scene or give other information. I read a lot on here about 'overwriting'. Yeah, you can cut the thing down to ten pages and it'll read faster. But it won't be as clear and it'll definitely be a lot harder to picture. There's also pacing to consider. But one man's meat is another's murder. And some people hate Elysium and like Michael Bay.


Quoted from Dreamscale
Biggest problem for me is the ending, as it falls flat as written, as if you ran out of room and couldn't really develop the finale you were after.  If you removed all the unnecessary detail early on, you'd have the room you want and need to properly close this out.  It's not a bad ending per se, but I was hoping for more and left unsatisfied.


Yeah, you're not alone in that. I think 'falls flat' is a bit strong, but then again, I would think that, wouldn't I? The ending was planned so I got where I wanted. It's a pity it wasn't where many others wanted to go. There was a few other ideas I had after, but I doubt they would have satisfied more.


Quoted from Dreamscale
Overall, this is strong and well done.  You created real mood and created characters that were both flawed and real, who I rooted for and understood, and that's tough to do, period, let alone in a week's time.

Congrats on a well thought out and pretty well written script.


Thanks very much.

Next.


Quoted from CoopBazinga
I do wish there was more action, did become a bit dull during the middle section and I don’t care how you put it, but reading about some guy drinking and watching television isn’t in the slightest interesting.


Oh dear. Didn't seem to bother most when Tony Soprano did it. But he was in the Sopranos. Which is like comparing a ringtone to Beethoven.

And Eric did need a rest as well as what he's watching is part of the plot, as well as a diversion. Looking back he didn't do it that much. But it did appear to make an undesired impression.


Quoted from CoopBazinga
Some things didn’t make sense to me… who was Brandon and what role did he play? Was this to tell us that Eric was some kind of dealer? His reaction to the missing Annie after getting back was also hard to take – she’s missing, so he goes back to drinking!? Huh? This is a guy who should and is desperate to get his family back so his reaction seemed… breezy.


Eric may have had some questionable dealings with Brandon, but he's not a dealer as such. His change later on is part of the plot.

Annie's missing. He rings her and can't get through. He could have phoned round but it's late and if you do, people will talk. So I've heard.

After he'd done what he had, Eric may have need of a drink or two. Breezy? What else should he have done?


Quoted from CoopBazinga
And the twist did lack some punch – I think it was obvious to be honest, but it may have been intended that way?


I think the end wasn't meant as a twist as such. You're meant to see it coming. But it has more ramifications than it's been given credit for. Or I may be trying to blow my own little trumpet and it's a bit flat.

Anyways, thanks to all who read and commented. I'll be here all week. Drive safely.


Out Of Character - updated


New Used Car

Green

Right Back

The Deuce - OWC - now on STS

Other scripts here
Logged
Site Private Message Reply: 22 - 30
rendevous
Posted: January 23rd, 2014, 10:49pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Away

Location
Over there.
Posts
2354
Posts Per Day
0.43

Quoted from Last Fountain
Fast paced. Intriguing. Emotional.


Oh yes. Now, this is far more like it. Nothing about it being too long or complaints about watching TV or the like. Or misplaced or missing commas. Keep going...


Quoted from Last Fountain
First, I love how this starts with the machine. And a cool steampunk design. We also immediately know it's dangerous as he exits bloody. Intriguing right away. Especially with his first words "is he back". You got me interested from the get go.


I couldn't have put it better myself. Don't stop...


Quoted from Last Fountain
The overall vibe was like Twilight Zone. A constantly building mystey. Is he a hitman sent to kill villains of the past? Or is he trying to correct something? I like how you made this a personal mission, trying to saved a loved one. I also liked the imagery of the coffin. He travels back because of death so it was darkly poetic.  As was the ending.


Well I have to say either you're a fan or this is Stevie having a laugh because his record player is broken and he's jammed the 'White Album' in his CD player. Either way, I like it.


Quoted from Last Fountain
I wish you told more about his daughter. Or a quick scene of him releasing his emotions. Otherwise I really enjoyed this. You kept me thinking. And it didn't get too scientific. We got the machine minus the technical details. In this case it was a good decision. You're focusing on emotional payoff. The human side. Not the sci-fi elements.

A sweetly dark poem to emotional loss.


Exactly. Although poem may be a bit... Hang on, daughter? I think you mean son. I'm not sure about him releasing his emotions. Eric prefers emptying bottles and tinkering with machines rather than punching walls. There's a lot of fellas like that.

I appreciate the compliments. Glad you liked it. Makes it all worthwhile.


Quoted from khamanna
I understood the idea behind it - he went back to change something and that altered the future in return.
THe idea behind it is simple and very easy to understand.
THe beginning is nice, slowly paced and well done.
But I didn't understand a lot in the middle. You describe his clothes in detail, every else, what people on the streets are doing - if you want to let us know the time changes you could just provide something small.


Oh well. This is a stark difference to Last Fountain's review. I can't quite agree that the middle is difficult to understand. I thought I was sparse with the detail and spare with the descriptions. All that's to give you an idea what the place looks like. I was showing, not telling. Would you really rather not know all that? Er, I think I can sense the answer.


Quoted from khamanna
I don't think you need this many pages for it. Or make them more interesting - either one.


Ouch.

I see the spirit of Pauline Kael is alive and well. Now I know how M. Night Shalamayan feels. Well, that's probably pushing it.

Thanks though! In my darker moments I can always reread that line and wonder why the hell I bother at all.
Then pace up and down dark streets drenched in rain while I consider why life is just a brief glimmer of light between two huge slabs of darkness...
Or I might put Laurel and Hardy on instead.


Quoted from MarkRenshaw
I liked the beginning, very atmospheric and mysterious...


Ah, now we're back to where we were -


Quoted from MarkRenshaw
...but the mystery was spread out too long, so I lost interest before it was revealed why he'd gone back in time in the first place.


- but not for long. That's a shame. All that plotting and pacing and working out. Wasted. Didn't mean a thing. Ah well, never mind. Now where is my Laurel and Hardy DVD gone? What do you mean, you don't know? You desert me...

Er, you need to adopt the indignant tones of Oliver Hardy for that last bit to work.



Quoted from MarkRenshaw
The time travel machine is never really explained, which isn't a problem but you have to ponder why his wife is working when they have the ability to make as much money as they want via time travel?


I could have explained the time travel machine. And then a load of people would have asked - Why did you explain the time travel machine in a time travel OWC challenge? So, I didn't.

Eric's wife Annie is a surgeon. They're not on the breadline. She works because she wants to. She comments on 'Somebody's got to be an adult around here' as she doesn't really like what he's doing and wishes he'd do something else.

As for going back and making money, that'd take a machine that would be able to deliver you to exactly the right moment a la Back to the Future. And, Great Scott!! Did The Doc not warn us all strenously about the huge dangers of going back to the past to place bets?

And let's not even think about getting into Primer. Nobody needs a headache right now.


Quoted from MarkRenshaw
Nicely done though, well written and I liked the drunken telephone conversation especially.


I thank you. More later, if I run out of Laurel and Hardy.


Out Of Character - updated


New Used Car

Green

Right Back

The Deuce - OWC - now on STS

Other scripts here
Logged
Site Private Message Reply: 23 - 30
oJOHNNYoNUTSo
Posted: January 27th, 2014, 2:02pm Report to Moderator
Been Around



Posts
817
Posts Per Day
0.19
Constant Escapement

The script was pretty easy to follow, sounds like it sucks to be Eric.  Actually, the concept itself would be an intriguing feature if you ask me.  I think it would be pretty crazy to see the rest play out from where it ended.

Good use of visual connotation in the opening passages.  A few incomplete sentences here and there that could've been combined but overall solid writing.  The pacing was good, but given the tone of the script, I thought there were some unnecessary details.

I realize Eric's motivation should be automatic, but i thought there was room for something greater between him and Annie to give the ending more punch.  I didn't care either way if Eric got screwed over in the present.

Johnny
Logged
Private Message Reply: 24 - 30
rendevous
Posted: January 27th, 2014, 8:07pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Away

Location
Over there.
Posts
2354
Posts Per Day
0.43
Hey oJOHNNYoNUTSo,

That's not so easy a name to say. Thank Kerriste for copy and paste. I'd almost forgotten about this script. You were kind on the whole. I wonder why so many dislike detail. Something I get told off about quite regularly.

You may be right about the end. If you didn't care either way then I missed a trick for you.

Thanks. I will respond to the other reviews when I get time, I hope.

R


Out Of Character - updated


New Used Car

Green

Right Back

The Deuce - OWC - now on STS

Other scripts here
Logged
Site Private Message Reply: 25 - 30
DustinBowcot
Posted: January 28th, 2014, 2:28am Report to Moderator
Guest User




Quoted from rendevous


Thanks for the kind comments at the start. As for the cereal bowl bit, I thought if I didn't mention the bowl then some smartarses, or perphaps dumbarses, would say hey, why is the guy eating cereal without a bowl? They'd have a image of him eating it straight out of the box or even eating barley straight from the field.
Erm, I think I've gone on quite enough about that now.


It wasn't that you mentioned the bowl that was my issue it was the grammar used to introduce it.



Quoted from rendevous

What? He can type on a keyboard. Presumably you mean mouse. I put it as is because I hate it in movies when a character is typing furiously away on a keyboard yet the monitor shows them flicking through menus and selecting stuff. Nobody's shortcut skills are that good. Maybe I shouldn't settle pet peeves in a script.


You wrote that he types 'with' a keyboard. I didn't feel that this was the correct word to use. I still don't.


Quoted from rendevous

Well, it depends on the jacket. He may have deep pockets or even just a hole in the lining. It maybe his special 'gun with silencer pocket' jacket that he keeps near his yoyo.

I'd say it's not that big of a stretch to go with it. He's not trying to fit a rocket launcher in the back pocket of his jeans or an AK47 down his sock.


Anyone would question a gun with silencer attached conveniently fitting inside a suit jacket.



Quoted from rendevous
Why wouldn't the coffin be able to get back? Jumping in time is alright but using a coffin shaped device to return isn't?

The idea was that he can get back home in the coffin shaped device by pressing a recall button. I didn't show it or state it as you don't get to see inside the coffin. His return journey is set up before he gets in the time machine to leave home.


Before the coffin left it was attached to wires and pipes etc that were obviously powering it. I had no idea how the coffin was going to get back without the same set up.


Quoted from rendevous
I'm not sure why 'aquaintainted?' makes the guy sound stupid. No, it's not deliberate. Not sure what you had in mind.


Because it is a mistake. The word is 'acquainted'.


Quoted from rendevous

Not to do what I was trying to do. Never let out a whoop, or something similar, that came out a bit too loud and you're trying to avoid attention?


Whoops by definition are loud.



Quoted from rendevous

Basic?


I like basic. Basic as in not overly complicated.


Quoted from rendevous
I didn't think 15 pages was enough to get into a complicated or convoluted story. Too long? Maybe. It could do with trimming and polishing. There ain't many scripts or films that wouldn't benefit from a good going over with the scissors.

More later. Maybe...


I didn't think it was complicated. Yes, trimming and polishing.

Good luck.
Logged
e-mail Reply: 26 - 30
rendevous
Posted: January 29th, 2014, 9:07pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Away

Location
Over there.
Posts
2354
Posts Per Day
0.43

Quoted from AtholForsyth
Great stuff, my favorite so far out of about 8.

The only thing that didn't ring true was when the ironmonger asked him if his gun was a Colt, I think that would be the last thing on his mind.

But all in all good s***.


I ran out of Laurel & Hardy.

Thanks AF. The old man asked him was it a Colt as he doesn't think he's actually gonna get shot and he's trying to engage in conversation. Plus he's never seen a gun like that before and he's interested. I think I doth protest a little too much.


Quoted from nawazm11
Well, the logline makes no sense so hopefully the script is different.


Oh dear. I see we're not starting off very gently. I'm not a fan of writing loglines. It ain't easy. I wouldn't say I was good at it but I would like to think I did write one that actually made some sense.


Quoted from nawazm11
First page is very overwritten, watch out for all that unneeded stuff.


Oooh, that's a bit of a kick in the cock.

And there I was trying to set up an atmosphere and some intrigue and mystery when all actually did was overwrite a load of unneeded stuff.


Quoted from nawazm11
Don't like him talking to himself/his dog.


Well, that's a shame. Works in loads of films and screenplays. But not mine, obviously.

I suppose I could have had him doing sign language with the dog, but I doubt that would have solved the problem.

Voice over? Be sure to get a kicking. Ah well.


Quoted from nawazm11
Machine kind of reminds me of the one from Primer.


I've forgotten what the actual machine was. I've vague memories of it being a metal container unit, The type they use as a lock up on building sites. I'd say this one was a bit different. I may seem argumentative, but I'm fairly sure nobody else will stick up for this thing.


Quoted from nawazm11
Twist wasn't anything original, kind of expected it but besides that, this was pretty good. Writing was fine, maybe a little overwritten at times, dialogue wasn't bad either which seems to be a big problem with all OWC entries. But I quite liked this. Good job.


I expected more of a kicking at the end, so I'm surprised and glad you seemed to like it.


Quoted from EWall433
A bit overwritten for my taste, but the story was taking me through it.


I detect a theme emerging,


Quoted from EWall433
A small nitpick, Page 2: “ERIC: We should change that wallpaper” First I thought you should cut it because I already understood the importance of the wallpaper from your description. Now I also think you should cut it because, if Eric’s the one who can’t let go, I don’t think he’d be the one to suggest tearing down the wallpaper.


I disagree. But then I'm bound to. He's just come back from another effort to save his son. He doesn't often come into the room and he's promised himself and his better half that he'd change that wallpaper which harks back to an era long passed, no matter what happens. I'd say he'd definitely say it.


Quoted from EWall433
I think the set-up/pay-offs of Brandon and the Priest are superfluous. We’ll still understand his reality’s been altered when he calls his wife’s office.


That's one way to look at it. And there was me thinking I was being entertaining and interesting.

Another would be to show, rather than tell, how what he'd done has affected many things in unexpected ways.


Quoted from EWall433
Once the momentum slowed down, I found myself wondering things you were probably hoping I wouldn’t ask. Like who is Eric that he has a machine like that? And why is he going back over 100 years when the event he’s looking to correct seems more recent.


All that's fine. Shows a little interest at the least. I'd be more worried if you'd concerned yourself with the antics of Justin Bieber.

At the start he returns from a failed attempt. He decides to go further back to try and be more successful as he's convinced himself about 'the whole bloody family'.


Quoted from EWall433
Overall I liked what you were going for here. Maybe it’s because it took so long to get there, but the twist had a ‘soft landing’ for me. I thought it could use more. Like what if the new wife was pregnant? Does he stay or does he go?

Decent work though and an enjoyable entry. Congrats.


Thanks. Maybe it could use more. But I like the idea of open ends and possibilities.


Out Of Character - updated


New Used Car

Green

Right Back

The Deuce - OWC - now on STS

Other scripts here
Logged
Site Private Message Reply: 27 - 30
rendevous
Posted: January 29th, 2014, 10:04pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer


Away

Location
Over there.
Posts
2354
Posts Per Day
0.43

Quoted from StevenClark
Hey Writer,
Pg 1: steam punk and Anthony Gormley? Maybe I'm out of the loop, but I don't know what this means.


Hey Steven. You may indeed be out of the loop. I may be too. I suspect those in the loop are being careful not to tell those out of the loop about how you can get in. The hairy barstards.

As for steampunk and Gormley, you could always have a look on a search engine. That sounds sarcastic. But what, can I only reference stuff I'm sure other people definitely know? It'd make it a bit dull.


Quoted from StevenClark
Lots of insects so far, a fly, a moth, a cicada, oh and a frog? Setting the scene or a deeper meaning?


Well, indeed. Some would call it overwriting. It may be they are very very busy and don't have the time for that kind of thing.


Quoted from StevenClark
Okay, this was not half bad. You could have done away with some of the exposition. The constant showbiz news on the TV was annoying.


Thanks. I can almost detect a compliment there. I could have done away with some of the stuff you call exposition and had some more heads scratching. As for the TV, he's flicking through channels and it's mentioned. It's going on in the background. I don't spend paragraphs detailing it. It's not like you have to watch it. It was more a comment on what might be on TV. It seems to have grated a little more than it should have.


Quoted from StevenClark
You had a very good set up here, but the ending left me scratching my head. So...who is this woman who's now his wife. Did Eric kill that man in the shop?  And if so, exactly how did this change the future?  See, the questions have no answers here, and I think they deserve to be answered. As it is it doesn't really make any sense.


Glad you liked the set up. Ah, head scratching. I'll try to explain. This woman who is now his wife, she's his wife.

Did Eric kill the man in the shop, and the other people upstairs? He did something, that's for sure as it's very different when he gets home. I could have shown him getting all Rambo and shooting loads of people. But I doubt that would have been fun for anyone.

It changed the future, or Eric's present, in many ways, as I detailed at the end. I thought there were lots of answers and it made sense. Others said it was too obvious, some of the changes were deemed superflous. I would despair, but it's only an OWC short script. It's not like that war in Syria or downtown Baghdad.


Quoted from StevenClark
Aside from that, your action blocks were written awkwardly at times and this piece could have been trimmed down. But, you still need to answer those questions!

A decent effort, though. Congrats on getting this done.
  

I'd say it all there to be found. Written awkwardly? That's a bit rough. Trimmed down? You could hurt my feelings here now. But you'll have to do a lot better than that.


Quoted from irish eyes
I actually found this pretty hard read, I had to go back over a few times just to understand what was happening.
  

Oh dearie me. Juding from your later summary you worked most of it out. I've been accused of overwriting by others. This is like that egg thing in Gulliver's Travels. Or maybe not.


Quoted from StevenClark
This one dragged on for me and as Steve pointed out without any suitable answers.
  

Oh dear. Another big kick in the cock. Ah well, nobody died, eh? It's not like there's a drone overhead and we're in Yemen.

Let's just leave that there.


Quoted from wonkavite
When I first cracked this open, I thought I would hate it, due to the dense description.  Surprisingly, I found that didn't get in the way... and I did find the story caught my attention.  Is the concept of wanting to go back and save one's son in any way unique?  Nah.  But it worked, for what it was... And the writing (despite the detail) was decent.


Seems many don't like my writing, or some of it at least. Good to know you thought it worked though.


Quoted from wonkavite
Until the very end, when the story just seemed to run out of steam.  The minute he couldn't find Annie, it was obvious the way this was going.


I know what you mean. I was trying, and evidently failing for some, to build tension and suspense.

Pity it wasn't obvious to some others. As for tension, I had to the misfortune to watch Somewhere the other day. It made my script seem like Terminator 2.


Quoted from wonkavite
And the main issue for me was, how exactly did killing Abe's relative tie in with Eric marrying someone else?  Yes, he changed the past, but what specifically changed in the time line to have this causality?  And in time travel stories, things like that are important.  The logic (such as it is with such things) has to gell and make sense.


Well, I could have spelt it all out then got a bollocking for doing so. Is leaving a little mystery in there so bad?

I'd disagree about the logic and having to make sense (for all). This is time travel. Killing a moth in the past could wipe out thousands of species by a huge stream of causality. Anyway, it made perfect sense to me. It still does when I read it. But I'm a bit bloody sick of it for now. So I may be back later. Talk amongst yourselves until then.

R


Out Of Character - updated


New Used Car

Green

Right Back

The Deuce - OWC - now on STS

Other scripts here
Logged
Site Private Message Reply: 28 - 30
ghost and_ghostie gal
Posted: March 10th, 2014, 7:53pm Report to Moderator
Old Timer



Location
A helluva long way from LA
Posts
1565
Posts Per Day
0.29
Hey RV,

Me, being a big sci-fy fan, I meant to comment  a while back, but got a bit sidetracked.  Better late than never I suppose...  

So Eric travels back into the past to try and change things.  Unfortunately, it doesn't seem to work that way.  In short, it didn't work as intended.  Things back fired on Eric.  I'm sensing an alternate reality in the end.   Did I get it wrong?  If so, please correct me.

I thought the story was simple and straightforward.  This was one of the better ones.

Ghostie


Logged
Private Message Reply: 29 - 30
 Pages: « 1, 2, 3 » : All
Recommend Print

Locked Board Board Index    January 2014 - One Week Challenge  [ previous | next ] Switch to:
Was Portal Recent Posts Home Help Calendar Search Register Login

Forum Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post polls
You may not post attachments
HTML is on
Blah Code is on
Smilies are on


Powered by E-Blah Platinum 9.71B © 2001-2006