We Are All Dust In The End by 0 - Short, Drama - A farming couple face the consequences of the drought from Hell.  - pdf format

Writer interested in feedback on this work

Hey writer,

Now, I'm confused. The story is very well done, it's absolutely bleak as all hell, but yet very well written. The pacing worked for the type of drama it was, there's no obvious typos and the formatting was nailed.

Why I'm confused is...who the hell is the author?? Having spent a decade down under, and technically being an Aussie, I can tell this author has either spent a significant period of time there, or has done a good bit of research. All the Aussies should logically be going COLD, but you went HOT. From Centrelink, to the dams you get on the country farms and also ute's, all nailed. Very mysterious...

Anyway, it was grim, a real tough read but perfectly executed and pretty darn good.

Aside from the mystery of the author amongst us, I'd say this is gonna be up there.

Cam

You need to tell us the opening line is a SUPER.  Then, you have 2 SUPERS in a row, which is odd.

Opening Slug missing a ".".  All Slugs seem to be missing a space.

Hmmm, you say it's 20 degrees C, which is 68 degrees F, which is neither hot nor cold, so we have a major problem right off the bat.

Page 1 is overwritten and dull.  It also ends way early on the page.

Passages not broken up correctly - keep 'em at 1 shot, 1 idea, 1 description.

And here lies the problem with this script - the writing...the passages specifically.  Fix these up to read quicker, shorter.

2nd in a row to use a song playing throughout most of the script - another smart choice, as it works very well here.

This is powerful and either from some kind of farmer or someone who did their research.  It's also very brutal and sad, but handled very smartly.

The pace seems slow, but that's mostly due to the overwriting and long passages.  This would look much better filmed than it reads.

It's well done.  I really like it.  Good work.

Well, I've a good idea who wrote this. Thank goodness it was the Who and not Kansas. Not a big fan of that song.

Good work, writer. I felt for the characters and their plight. Wasn't expecting the text at the end. More expecting dark clouds and rain. Sad, just the same.

We are all Dustin - The end. Though I don't think it's his.

Good choice of setting - struggling farmers, desperate people do desperate things

The playing of music over the top does work to a degree, but also confuses it IMO. But I give you this, setting a story over a song isn’t easy.

The twist at the end is a sad one. It isn’t bad but something feels off about it, not sure what. Maybe I just don’t like the outcome. Or maybe if their was to be a twist it was always going to be that their actions were pointless, I suppose. It as though I would have preferred the farmer to know this, just not believe it.

For a weeks work a fair effort.

Eh?

This story needs more. Something to drive it. To raise the stakes. Show us a mountain of unpaid bills to set the stage they are in debt and in big trouble, not just from the drought. As is, the man just kills sheep and there isn't as much reason for it I think as there should be. Also, not sure why he kills himself at the end. That came outta nowhere and was unbelievable. They are not desperate enough. I don't feel the man is at the end of his rope yet.

Hard to do all this in 6 pages with no dialogue. Good effort but needs more to make it work.

Writer,

Not bad. I liked the song playing, then rising once the window is shattered. Pretty bleak story, but the writing, though prose-like, kinda carried me along with this. Little JAWS reference in there too with the eyes. I caught that. Anyway, pretty good job.

Steve

This one reads too prosy to me, but the story is very strong. Actually made me feel something, so great work on that.

I would skip mentioning the temperature. We can see that it's extremely hot and a drought.

I think it would work better to have some clouds building in the sky after she kills herself rather than a text about some government relief, but maybe that's just me.

Great job!  

I'm torn because it's a good story. I think this would look great filmed. But I wouldn't say I enjoyed the read. It's just too much detail of every movement... even most thoughts of the characters. It did read like prose. But almost intentionally so, like you were deadset on getting a certain atmosphere and not too concerned with how fast it read. I do think a good filmmaker could do something special with this.

The opening line I would have thought is

TITLE OVER BLACK: ?

First off, I love the name of your Short.

Great on point and succinct character descriptions.
Lovely description of the Farmer’s Wife, understated but says it all.

But even in the winter the temp is a mild 20 Celsius,
and its so dry...

Outside of this challenge this is going to work better imho, if the drought is depicted under a blood red sun, and it’s stinking hot, people are dripping in sweat, hard yakka etc.

I thought at first with the Jerrycans he was going to set fire to the animals?

Lovely descriptions with the dam and surroundings – can picture it all perfectly. Great job. I’m not finding the dense paras too much at all. Doesn’t need dialogue and doesn’t feel as if dialogue should be there.

I liked the way the Farmer killed one of the crows – showing his fury at the injustice of it all.**

Terrific use of silence and the Farmer's Wife becoming alert because of this. That'd be a great moment.

On screen by page three he's shot about half of the flock. Be up to the director but that’d be some carnage to see on screen, a bit punishing – perhaps the option of using the sound of the gun only, after a point?

Perhaps have this line below on a new line – new subject/shot.

His wife is standing now, watching him carefully.

At this point:
Pushing the phone back into the pocket, she runs...

I'd have her already move closer before she takes off running (for her to see him lock the ute doors), she seems too far away in the beginning - and then focus on her running. This is where you could amp up the tension and suspense even more. She's effectively running to save her husband’s life at this point.

**I think you could add something to the wildlife visual too, there's a feature missing from your script:

Something like:
Along the back fence hundreds of kangaroos whip backwards and forwards (Wild Rabbits too). Undeterred by the gun shots, arrogant, waiting for food.

Roos are in direct competition for food during drought and usually they’re winning, despite casualties. Around fourteen million of them in NSW alone, up from seven million in 2010. I've seen it up close and personal. The Farmer’s rage would likely turn to him taking a potshot at a couple of Roos at least, and the sound of further shots in their direction seeing them scatter, but ultimately returning, not deterred.

These words below, imho, should be on a separate line of their own too:

His wife runs across the paddock, dust kicking up from her feet.

To aid again in the rhythm and increased suspense.

I wonder too if instead of calling her 'his wife,' it’s a little removed. Calling her by name (and him too) may make the read more effective so that your audience/reader, at least, feels it, more personally, right where she is.

Focus on the sound of her breaths, frantic, feet flying, sound of her cries and wails perhaps, as she can see what he's about to do, getting closer and closer, desperately trying to get to him to stop him. I'd include her 'banging on the car window MOS, in addition to what you've written already.

I could picture the crowbar falling soundlessly into the dust, then the sound coming back up with the smashing of the window, the bleats, the caws etc.

Bravo, on expertly weaving the lyrics around the action.

You've written this with raw emotion we can really feel, and evoked the visuals terrifically.

Imagining this as a film I can’t help feeling though that it’s too grim, too bleak.

I'd like to think one of them is a survivor, that perhaps she sees something in the end to change her mind and battle on. The irony of course is the Text message.

I'd give no open credit to Centrelink btw -  make it generic: govt assistance instead.

Rain finally falling would be the ultimate irony.

The Farmer’s Wife getting soaked to the skin by rain, sobbing and screaming to the heavens in the final frame will probably be too much of a happy ending for you, I predict?, but it could also provide some much needed relief for an audience, and a message of hope.

Impressive work, writer. Really well done.

P.S. Its / it's bone dry p.2
Is the only typo that stuck out.

Right out of the gate...

1. Title is not ALL CAPS,
2.

Quoted Text [SUPER:] PARTS OF AUSTRALIA ARE EXPERIENCING THE WORST DROUGHT SINCE 1900

3. and you never faded in.

Very poor start. I'll give you credit for the Dust in the Wind reference.

If that weren't bad enough, when you finally DO decide to SUPER, you use a hyphen instead of a colon. I'm giving you one page to correct course, or I'm out.

It's DAY, not AFTERNOON. DAY and NIGHT are the preferred time indicators, and sometimes DUSK and DAWN, but use those sparingly.

Again, I'm giving you one page.

Quoted Text The FARMER[ ](50)[ ]steps

Nope. Is your space bar broken, by any chance? The writing is terrible so far.

It's "rolled[-]up sleeves", but I'll forgive that one.

Muscled forearms? A farmer? Is he supposed to be Arnold or Rambo?

An Akubra is a Crocodile Dundee-style Aussie hat.

20 C = 68 F. Not overly hot.

Quoted Text its so dry

it's = it is
its = possessive

So you're saying that the 20 Celsius owns a "so dry" (whatever the hell that is) and you don't even finish a sentence that already makes no sense?

A "ute" is a utility vehicle, not a Ute Indian, correct?

I had to google what a jerrycan was.

Wait? He pouts the gun in the gas tank? Or does he put the jerrycan and the gun in the passenger or backseat of the Ford?

Quoted Text Back into the shed, and out with several boxes of ammunition for the rifle[,] [finish the sentence]

I give up. I'm out.

Coincidences are a weird thing. Eating my lunch today I watched the news go on about a drought in Australia and farmers are struggling to water their livestock. Then I read this!

Well written but from a prose perspective. There's way too much detail and over emphasising the action. It is way too specific. If you cut all that down to the bare bones so to speak, you'll then have more room for story and character development, which are the key elements that a script needs beyond impressive descriptions.

Nice twist at the end, grim and atmospheric but needs a lot of work to become a screenplay in my opinion.

Great effort though for a week and the writer can write.

-Mark

Starting with OVER BLACK seems like a missed opportunity to me here.

Some of the images related to drought are truly astonishing. You could set up the whole story with a couple of impactful shots and forget the SUPERS altogether. A 'No Swimming' sign in the foreground with a bone dry lake behind it maybe. Or an animal's corpse, decomposing under the midday sun in a barren landscape... Okay, further on and can see there's plenty of them to go around so maybe ignore that last point.

Not overly sure what to think of this as a whole.

I think you nailed the theme of the challenge and the no dialogue parameter worked well.

Writing was fine for the most part. Few unfilmables and the odd spelling mistake here and there. But not bad for a week.

I felt the characters' desperation to a point, maybe not enough for the actions they took.

The main thing that bugged me was the relief payment angle. If it was such a big deal, why doesn't the wife just show her husband the phone through the window? She had it in her hand about two seconds earlier.

That whole scene just felt a little too contrived.

I don't know, maybe the two suicides in such a short space of time was too much for me.

Good effort. But needs a little re-working to be great IMO.  

This was sad and predictable... Unnecessary carnage going on and really no need to kill themselves and all their livestock especially if they just waiting on approval based on the text.

Also using a  famous song throughout will never get directed in a short IMO

The writing was good and you obviously met the parameter with heat.

Good job on entering

So did she read the message or didn't she? That part was confusing. Because if she did read it then she should have shown it to him when she was banging on his window. If she didn't, well, why? Was she in such a hurry that she didn't have time to look at the message and had time putting it in her back pocket? I don't know. I'm not buying it.

I hated the fact that I didn't know where this was going as I reached page three or so. I wish you have established the possibility of him committing suicide early on somehow. Because even though him jumping in the car and locking the doors surprised me but the surprise had a weaker impact since there was no overshadowing or any sort of setup. It jumped at me out of nowhere.

Other than that bit of nitpicking, this was a solid drama about hope and despair. Thanks for participating.