Wamphyr by Mario Perrotta (coldsnap) writing as Mario Perrotta (coldsnap) writing as ? - Short, Horror - To stop an ancient evil, a band of soldiers must resurrect something much worse. - pdf format

Writer interested in feedback on this work

I think this was both a success and a failure. My feelings are the story was too big for the short length. The amount of exposition to establish the world was more akin to a novel than a short screenplay or comic, imo. There was so much exposition that reading it was something of a chore.

I liked the atmosphere and the tone but I think you needed to get the setting established much more quickly and get to the bones of the story.

The way they were so easily able to defeat Dracula also undid the emphasis you'd put on the danger of reviving him.

I thought this was an interesting read.

The ending feels like there was an error.  I thought Mina was bitten on her neck only for her to have a spike her chest.  Separately, I think all this blood pushes the boundaries of a PG.

The lunar cycle is like a month.  So the Sikaar are attacking every 13 months.  It seems strange that the King dies and suddenly 13 months later he's this great monster.  Mina is also 32, so this monster legacy can't have lasted for long.  Plus, he'd have to be revived fairly often.

I really think if this story was longer it would flow better.  The tight constraints harmed the impact of the story.

All the best.

A 'bloodied footprint' might have been visually more startling p.2. Imho.

The 'red eyed undead on horseback' instantly reminded me of the creepy white walkers in GOTs. Nice image.
Feren seemed to escape them easily? Ah, okay, he furtively backed out of there.

So far so good, nice cross fantasy/vampire tale but I'd reconsider the V.O. which took me out of the flow. Plain dialogue would suffice?

P.7 should be 'beside him now' - typo 'his' fyi.

Mina drives the silver spike through his chest but it has little effect and she's still bitten.? Hmm, okay, I'll go with it.

I like this. Very nice visuals for the comic format, just something missing in the execution of it   which I can't put my finger on. Perhaps if Drakul was released in the midst of battle to save the day? Nice work.

I felt that you could have shortened the opening, compressing the VO dialogue and gone straight to the action. A few typos. Could have ended with who rules Wallachia now that Drakul and Mina are undead.

This was too overwritten for my taste. With a three page comic in mind, it could have started at the crypt with a couple short captions to give backstory. If this is selected, that's probably what they would need to do to make it fit.

Great imagery and action sequences for illustrations. The story just needs to be compressed. My big question: How does Drakul kill the undead? Is it just that he tears them apart? And what's in it for Drakul to do this for the living?

Pretty ambitious work for three pages of comic. Good work, writer.

I thought this was very well done.

Also, pretty sure the writer studied the existing comics at HyperEpics. I'm betting they noted the text boxes as a tool for laying out exposition... and decided VO was the script equivalent.

That said, I felt the VO was a bit overdone. Would have liked to get to the action sooner.

Due to style and story, I think this has a chance to be chosen.

I personally think there is way too much dialogue for a 3 page comic. It would be a real struggle to get everything in.

The story felt more like a fantasy with the creature feature element shoehorned in.

While you were going for that classic horror end with the eyes shooting open, that really doesn’t work for me, and it goes against the logic you have set for the piece. The silver spike is either enough to contain them or it isn’t. Why are her eyes shooting open?

Lots of creativity, so I did quite enjoy it. I don’t think it suits the challenge, but I do think the story is well worth turning into a bigger piece.

All the best.

Exposition overload. You could cut all of the VO at the beginning as the characters explain what is going on. Even so, their dialogue could do with a polish to sound more natural.

Nice usage of the Dracula legend. Visually this would work well for a comic. It just needs more work and a lot of trimming.

Congrats for completing OWC.

This felt like a movie. lol. Very expensive but still a movie. lol.

Maybe during the VO, have the scenes back it up? Like show the dragon, the war etc. Can't wait to find out who this is and read more of your work. lol.

Gabe

Narration/dialogue could do with a trim.  As written the words would tend to overpower the action blocks.

It’s minor, but do the silver spikes work to keep them ‘dead’ or not?  The ending feels like something of a false note otherwise.

A decent idea, not really my sort of thing but there's a certain satisfaction in bad guys meeting their demise at the hands of an even worse character.  Could do with a leaner, tighter form of world-building to streamline the set-up.

Feels a little bit bloated, lots of exposition to wade through before the story kicks in. Might work better with a few more pages an not for this parameter of the OWC.  Not terrible by any means, but seems a bit bland....although the setting is nice.

Since it could be intended for a visual medium...wouldn't it be wonderful to show me a dragon instead of telling me about it?

We don't start with a FADE IN, but I like your opening Slug alot!  You've set your scene here and I know right where we are.

I don't like the 2 passages that follow, though - both end in an unnecessary orphan and you repeat your Slug in the opening passage.

Nice use of the SUPER!  Now we know exactly where we are and when.

OK, so through the end of Page 2, we have lots of background info, as well as some nice visuals, but IMO, this would not transfer to the comic format we're after, as everything is fed to us through VO.  Lots of orphans running around here, too, which need to be looked into - 6 in all, which means 6 wasted lines in 2 pages.  For short shorts, this is a problem.

Page 3 - You've got a 7 line passage here and it's a mess.  Don't go over 4 lines - EVER.  Just no need for it.  This is not broken up correctly.  Break up the individual intros after the action lines about Feren approaching.

Sadly, the dialogue exchange doesn't sound remotely realistic.

I feel like I've seen these scenes play out in an actual movie...or maybe movies.  Most of the action is skirted over with VO, but this is still a bloody, bloody script, and unlikely PG rated.  It's also absolutely a HUGE budget and it's extremely unlikely this would transfer well to the comic we're after.

Things go downhill on the last 2 pages, as if the RUSH to finish was on and the final shot doesn't work for me.

IMO, this is much too big a concept for a short short and it feels like a mere scene from a movie about Drakul.  Not bad, though.

Grade - ** 1/2

That was good stuff. Doesn't really feel like a short but I still enjoyed it. Seemed more like an opening to a fantasy/action movie. I could see it cutting to present day right after that and introducing our hero.

Other than the exposition being a bit overdone, the dialogue and everything else was quite good. Write it as a feature!

A lot exposition happening which easily have been trimmed down.

I did enjoy reading it although I pictured more of a mini movie than a comic strip.

One of the better entries but not my fav

Good job on entering