Print Topic

SimplyScripts Screenwriting Discussion Board  /  Screenwriting Class  /  Rewriting
Posted by: Peter Parker, April 17th, 2005, 3:01pm
I'm an "overwriter" That seems to be the only word that i can use to describe it, but i think that when i'm writing dialougue I write too much. Sometimes it's good and clever sometimes it's forced and overdone and it seems to end up covering up things that are lacking in a scene.

Anythoughts on how to overcome this and still maintain my desire to be more clever than the next guy.
Posted by: Chris_MacGuffin, April 17th, 2005, 3:03pm; Reply: 1
I find I have the same problem, I tend to write for monologues and then I slack on the descriptions, you know.
Posted by: TheProducer, May 18th, 2005, 12:28am; Reply: 2
Don't worry about overwriting on your first draft.  In fact... I encourage it.  But then, put the script down for a couple days.  Don't think about it, if you can.  Then go back and, as William Faulkner said, "Kill your darlings".  Cut what you love.  The more it hurts, the tighter it gets.  Because chances are... when you try too hard to be clever... often times you fail.

Let it come naturally.  And as you cut... you'll find the moments.

(This is advice I fail to follow often, by the way.  But I do try and try)

When it comes to desription... paint the picture but then let the dialogue move the action.
Posted by: Impulse, June 24th, 2005, 5:31pm; Reply: 3
I have the same problem. When I'm writing dialogue, I'll say to myself "that's funny, clever, and smooth" but once I go over in the rewrites, I say "god, how corny." But I have no trouble cutting things out - whatever I question I cut or switch around and rewrite again. Anything to make the story better, you know?
Posted by: dogglebe (Guest), June 24th, 2005, 6:33pm; Reply: 4

Quoted from TheProducer
Don't worry about overwriting on your first draft.  In fact... I encourage it.  But then, put the script down for a couple days.  Don't think about it, if you can.  Then go back and, as William Faulkner said, "Kill your darlings".  Cut what you love.  The more it hurts, the tighter it gets.  Because chances are... when you try too hard to be clever... often times you fail..


A couple of days?  After I finish with the first draft, I put it down for a couple of weeks and work on something else.


Phil

Posted by: George Willson, June 24th, 2005, 8:57pm; Reply: 5
I am with the couple of weeks. A couple of days is always too soon for me. I still love what I've done and can't separate myself from it enough to start with the cutting. After a few weeks, I can be objective enough to start in with the left brain.
Posted by: bodegage, July 29th, 2005, 8:07pm; Reply: 6
Lets all talk about how we rewrite our screenplays. See if we have any new ideas or suggestions.

I personally leave my script for two weeks, then read it over as a screenplay. If I still think it's gods gift to screenplays I leave it for another two weeks and try again.

If I start to notice problems, or I'm thinking it can be improved, I reread the entire story and make notes on possible story changes. I go over my outline and incorporate/remove story elements based on my notes.

After that, I go through every scene and objectively look at it to see how it could be improved, or if it is even needed.


Posted by: George Willson, July 29th, 2005, 8:47pm; Reply: 7
I generally leave it alone for a couple of weeks and reread it. From there, I either make minor edits as I go, or if it has real issues, I tear it apart and rework it. I take rewriting as a given on screenwriting or any writing. I know I'll screw it up the first time through and have to go back and fix it later.
Posted by: Impulse, July 29th, 2005, 9:08pm; Reply: 8
I wait a couple to a few weeks, sometimes longer, and reread it once without making any notes then I go back over it and write down what I want to change about it. [This script I'm working on, I changed it completely around and wrote about two pages of notes of new ideas.] Then, after I get all my notes in order, I go back to the keyboard and type it afresh. I hardly think, I mean, I never think my work is perfect so I can tear it apart as many times as I want and I always find something I can change, always.
Posted by: Mr.Z, August 1st, 2005, 10:01am; Reply: 9
The "leave it for two weeks" technique works well for me as well. But I also use another one: I read my script once a day during, lets say a week. After many readings, the good parts are still pleaseant to read, while the crappy ones start to annoy me. Then I know, those parts need a rewrite.
Posted by: Impulse, August 1st, 2005, 12:54pm; Reply: 10
That sounds like a good idea, Z, maybe I should try that.
Posted by: George Willson, August 1st, 2005, 1:14pm; Reply: 11
Impulse, I rather like your idea of retyping the whole thing. I think it's a good practice to have. I think I'll have to try that some time along with Mr. Z's reading it daily idea. May help to fix my dalogue issues (sometimes it sounds forced).

I'm hoping we get some more ideas on this part, since it's where a lot of writers really break down. They get draft one done and call it complete. It never is...
Posted by: R.E._Freak (Guest), August 1st, 2005, 7:06pm; Reply: 12
I never stop working until I finish a script. All of my good ideas come to me on the fly. Basically, I write whatever comes to mind the first time based on whatever rough planning I came up with. That's my first draft, usually ranges from 80 - 100 pages (long, yes, hence why I'm working on a novel). From there I pick random scenes to edit, so that I don't have the flow and I don't just end up reading it. It's like reading something backwards. You pick up on things that don't fit right away, as you don't know the immediate context of the surrounding scenes. Once I finish that (usually increases by about 10 pages) I do a linear rewrite where I rewrite the entire script word for word. I play with the word combinations, scene order, etc. Basically, I use the draft as an extensive outline for a new version. It's time consuming but you really get to know the material, so it becomes easy.
Posted by: dangeroussamurai, August 1st, 2005, 10:51pm; Reply: 13
I work exactly like the Freak.  I write a quick first draft with all the scenes that I think are nessasary or at least relatively so, then I edit a second draft taking out the crap and rearranging the good or adding better, then a third fixing wording errors, sentences, etc.  Then I read it really carefully and if the images that come to mind aren't the ones I imaged...well, screw that script for now. >_>
Posted by: quadmanjt, August 2nd, 2005, 9:17am; Reply: 14
I also tend to try and rewrite the entire thing.  This always helps me find a better way to label a discription or change dialouge.  Once I get done reading the first and final are like night and day.
Posted by: shelbyoops (Guest), September 2nd, 2005, 8:59pm; Reply: 15
How is drafting done exactly? Is it just you pull up the script and add/take out stuff? Do you re type the whole thing and add/take away as you re type? none of the above? Please help me! :)
Posted by: George Willson, September 2nd, 2005, 9:29pm; Reply: 16
Are you referring to rewriting? If that is the case, it is however works best for you. I know some who use the first draft and then retype it, cleaning as they go. Others use red ink all over one draft and then fix whatever they've marked up. I just read what I've written making changes as I go.

Ideally, before you rewrite you take a few weeks away from it (at least two) and then look over it with a fresh mind and be overly critical of it. You have to make sure what flowed out during your first draft actually works. Youmight even find the whole thing needs an overhaul (reorganizing scenes, scrapping some scenes, writing new ones, reworking characters).

Rewriting is a necessary evil here, but it's not all that bad. Did that answer your question?
Posted by: Scoob, September 3rd, 2005, 1:30am; Reply: 17
I was dreading rewriting any thing I had ever done until I found I enjoyed doing it.
You can see the mistakes, and can take them out,  alter the dialouge ect.

It sounded pretty drab until you start doing it, I actually enjoyed it.

You dont need to change the whole scene, just a line.

Posted by: Old Time Wesley, September 3rd, 2005, 4:26am; Reply: 18
You see I think re-writing is better when you have 2 or more writers working on 1 project... Let's take an idea for example, one guy writes the screenplay, gives it off to a new guy who goes through fixing it and changing parts they don't like. If after that the script isn't to both person(s) liking you go back to the first guy who does the same and so on until you both like it.

I think if more writers did it this way we'd have more produced than unproduced writers.

when you're so close to something you can't always see the mistakes (Which is why people should post screenplays) but as I've noticed some people post them to shock and disturb as the one guy put it. Basically all the wrong reasons and they take up valuable space where people who actually need the reads don't get anything.
Posted by: shelbyoops (Guest), September 3rd, 2005, 10:41am; Reply: 19
Thank you guys! you all have been a big help!!! :)
Print page generated: May 5th, 2024, 11:57pm