Print Topic

SimplyScripts Screenwriting Discussion Board  /  Short Scripts  /  Manhattan Madam
Posted by: Don, October 18th, 2015, 3:08pm
Manhattan Madam by CJ Walley - Short, Drama - Following a violent fight, a bordello madam faces off with a fearsome customer and finds herself torn between securing future profits and protecting her staff. 12 pages - pdf, format 8)
Posted by: RKeller, October 19th, 2015, 10:58am; Reply: 1
Minor distractions
- A few times you use your, when it should be you're, and ain't has an apostrophe.  This distracts.
- Pg 8: He binds his fists fuming. Meaning?
- Not sure the significance of the Thorello drink? He refuses, says yes later, then let's Rupert choose, with umbrella?  This is a guy used to being in charge, in control, so he'll gonna make specific demands and stick to them, and bristle at an umbrella
- A phone rings in the side-room. Was that a door bell?

Major distractions
- The dialogue vacillates between cliche and awkwardly expository, especially between Madam and Rupert.  He works closely with (in?) her so they would be more familiar, no?
- What's the purpose of the check? One of her employees caused damages, and he offers money in restitution?
- The bluff appearance of Cooch smacks of deus ex machina

Good
- Many of your verbs and adjectives are excellent: pins, canter, glide, balletic poise
Posted by: eldave1, October 19th, 2015, 11:05am; Reply: 2

Quoted from RKeller
Minor distractions
- A few times you use your, when it should be you're, and ain't has an apostrophe.  This distracts.
- Pg 8: He binds his fists fuming. Meaning?
- Not sure the significance of the Thorello drink? He refuses, says yes later, then let's Rupert choose, with umbrella?  This is a guy used to being in charge, in control, so he'll gonna make specific demands and stick to them, and bristle at an umbrella
- A phone rings in the side-room. Was that a door bell?

Major distractions
- The dialogue vacillates between cliche and awkwardly expository, especially between Madam and Rupert.  He works closely with (in?) her so they would be more familiar, no?
- What's the purpose of the check? One of her employees caused damages, and he offers money in restitution?
- The bluff appearance of Cooch smacks of deus ex machina

Good
- Many of your verbs and adjectives are excellent: pins, canter, glide, balletic poise


R and others - just a heads  up - CJ does not respond to comments on his scripts (not even sure he wants them - it's just his thing/philosophy).

Print page generated: May 7th, 2024, 8:35am