for the record, I'd totally be down for a Vegas or gambling themed challenge.  

I'm so curious about Carson's review of loglines that I can't keep still.

Will it affect our voting if we saw them though - it's just a title and logline. But, yeah, don't pay attention to me)

Quoted from khamanna I'm so curious about Carson's review of loglines that I can't keep still. Will it affect our voting if we saw them though - it's just a title and logline.

That's why I'm not posting those until after your voting deadline.  

Thanks Libby.

I think my logline was pretty good, so I am interested to see what they thought.
I think that I might get good scores for originality but get low on execution.

I am dying to talk about my story but am waiting.  I will say this, not one person picked up on my hidden clues or Easter eggs.   That tells me that in the future, I really need to simplify things.

You know what's odd?  Years ago, I took a theater writing class and was dinged for not having a deep enough vocabulary.  Now, cue 30 years later and people have dinged my script for having words they don't know and how a reader might toss a script aside if there are too many words they don't understand.  It's crazy.  

I do think I have a decent story.  However, my favs were the ones I listed above.  There were some outstanding entries.

Any idea who wrote what?  Sadly, a few did correctly guess mine.  I guess I have a pretty distinctive style, but I don't really understand what that is.

Since I submitted it, I've had a ton of ideas on making it better.

Dan

Dan, I'm almost positive which one is yours.

I also know a few others, but the vast majority, I don't know.

For me, there are 2 winners, and it's a pretty simple choice, as most of these got very low marks from me.

Dream, I got you for "Perseverance".

One question: We can vote on Friday?

@ whatever I hope so, and go sleep

Quoted from PrussianMosby Dream, I got you for "Perseverance".

Perseverance?  Hmmm...I don't think I read that one...

All done and voted!

12 excellents
4 very goods
4 goods
3 fairs
7 poors
And my script
And I didn't care much for the one that got withdrawn (forgot its title)

I guess I can go back to my life now.

Just voted!

0 excellent
4 very good
10 good
12 fair
3 poor

haven't read the one where the writer didn't review

+ had Ruby originally on a 3 (good)


Good challenge, everyone.

Thanks to Don and Pia.

My favorites are (in no particular order)

The Magician Of Peacock Springs
The 5th Horseman
Nero
The Last Days of Demons

I do have a few others I really liked but didn't quite hit the Excellent mark.

-Mark

Quoted from PrussianMosby + had Ruby originally on a 3 (good)

I'd second that. Wanted another read of it, shame it's gone

Voted. No excellents, but a few Very Good's:

The 5th Horseman
For Honey or Gold
Perseverance
A Toast To Armageddon
Play Dead

The rest fell below the mark. Great challenge. Can't wait to see who wrote what and how all did. Good luck!

When is deadline for voting?

Quoted from CameronD When is deadline for voting?

I think it is today.....I think.

It is today.  Get the votes in.  Stop dillydallying around.

We've had 2 complete weeks.  No excuses.  Let's get this thing over with, already!