I'll confess to being the person who voted for "The Girl Without Hands", though I also voted for four other scripts.

I acknowledge the complaints about the quality of writing, but I personally enjoyed reading it. It was fun to see a take on an obscure Brothers Grimm tale well suited to the horror genre, instead of yet another take on "Snow White" or "Red Riding Hood" filled with cannibalism...

The other four scripts I voted for were...

Ugly Beautiful - This worked as a revenge story, because the writer made me hate the antagonists with a burning passion, and made the protagonist sympathetic enough for her later actions to be understandable.

Would Not Tell A Lie - Very well-written. It was nice to see a happy ending, in contrast to the mostly bleak scripts in the OWC

The Final Curse of the Blue Smoke - Another story which I liked for using obscure and interesting source material. This was probably my favourite script in the contest, as it was well-written and placed an interesting modern-day spin on the story type.

The Boy and the Wolves: A Reimagining - The writing was evocative, and there were some interesting ideas about the lessons which fairy tales can teach us.