Quoted from eldave1 I am even willing to go 1A and 1B

I'll agree to that.  

~Zack~

If Congress outlawed football, but gave us one more year, so next is the last, and everyone was declared a free agent, who would you start with? For one year. 33 year old Rodgers? or 40 year old Brady?

Well that's your most valuable player.

I would go with Brady. Sure, Rodgers is faster and throws it further. But winning a title is a long process that begin in June. Brady pushes and studies and builds. That's the reason the always get there. And once there, he reads defenses better and makes generally better decisions. Getting there so many times is not an accident.