Hey Bo,
Sorry for the long delay between reads but life got in the way. Anyway, I finished this today between a few tantrums from my daughter. >
The opening 18 pages felt clunky to me for some reason, maybe it was the over the top character descriptions or the fact that you were trying to pile so much conflict into Kevin’s life for the latter scenes. Not sure but it needs to be reworked IMO.
When we got the Old West, things picked up, the story flowed better although most of the new characters were poor.
Jed was good, no complaints from me here, he’s a good character with a lot of potential and Adriana was okay, She has Eva Mendes written all over her. Apart from July who gave a great cameo, liked his 10 pages or so even if he did die stupidly IMO (in notes), everyone else struggled from here on in.
They wasn’t bad, just undeveloped, no personalities and some of them had long, over extravagant descriptions and then never saw them again. Characters like: Maria, Harper, Fat Lucy for example.
It was Kevin who was the main disappointment for me and this isn’t good if he is the main protag. I liked him in the first 20 pages but then he seemed to take a back step for Jed and Adriana.
His relationship with Grace needs to be more developed before he goes back to the Old West, why does he like her? What is their connection? She’s only just started working there?
Snake, although the name felt unoriginal wasn’t a bad antag but he could have done with some back up. Apart from Garrett, it was mainly unused extras or “banditos” and something felt missing from this gang? Give them some unique personalities and traits.
Like I say, it flowed nicely when we got to Old West, felt there were some problems with the slugs which I’ve mentioned in the notes but overall the plot moved nicely along. There were some inconsistencies but even a lot of produced movies have them.
The dialogue was okay, I honestly thought this would be the main problem but it worked for me, you did a good job overall. I’m not saying it’s perfect but good.
I did feel the ending felt rushed, could do with expanding, felt too easy to stop the gatlin gun but like how you tied the catapult opening into this, that’s a nice touch and good structurally for our protag.
Kevin’s return and change could work but like I said earlier, I didn’t care enough about his and Grace’s relationship to care. If this is reworked, developed earlier, it will add more meaning, care for the reader.
Anyway, these are just my thoughts. Best of luck with this.
These are the notes I took during the read:
P. 25 Does “drunk” need to be capped throughout the action?
Try to avoid “ing” words if there unnecessary. “Knocking him out cold” could be “Knocks him out cold”
P. 26 Again, should “outlaw” be capped in the action?
P. 29 Maria doesn’t have an age?
Where did the townswoman come from? She was just suddenly there? Was she with Maria?
P. 30 Some of Kevin’s dialogue could do with some polishing, sometimes comes across as too formal for the character you’ve developed.
P. 31 “HARPER's beard is a bird's nest” is it literally a birds nest? The “s” on the end Harper should be capped. Again, no age here and intro feels long.
“I asked if I can help ya.” Missing question mark.
“Jed stays in shadow.” Wonder if this should read “Jed stays in the shadows”
P. 33 “women with men can't do for 'em.” Is there a “it” missing between do and for?
P. 34 “Jed's looks run the gamut from frustration to total frustration” This was a weird sentence, I’m guessing the horse is the one frustrated but how do you show a frustrated horse? Is the horse frustrated or exhausted?
“almost on purpose” I don’t know? I personally don’t like this line, Is it on purpose or not? I mean why not, “he purposely jumps from the horse”
P. 36 JED
I expect that went pretty well.
“think” instead of “expect” would be better suited here in this line IMO.
“failing at casual.” Is this supposed to be “failing at being casual”
“Adriana takes a drink.” Change to something like “Adriana takes the drink for herself” Reads better IMO.
P. 37. (usually a lot) How do we know this?
Have noticed a few “more” in the sluglines like:
EXT. RANCH HOUSE – MORE
I’ve never seen this and it has left me a bit baffled, do you mean continuous?
Can a door slam open? I guess if it hits something but I would make this clearer.
P. 38 Adriana’s dialogue should be (O.S) as she’s still in the ranch but scene is outside. Actually, neither of Jed or Adriana left, the door just opened. Just a thought.
“She's a four-alarm fire.” Okay, I’m curious to know what this means?
“No talking this trip.” Missing “on” between talking and this.
P. 39 “Kevin has rediscovered his romance with the West and even the nag beneath him plays it cool this go 'round.”
Sorry but this whole sentence reads wrong IMO. More telling and awkward phrasing.
Have a look at the opening sentence in the sheriff’s office, also a bit awkward IMO.
“We ain't head a proper hanging in almost six months.” Is head a typo? Is it supposed to be had? Or a pun because it’s quite a funny line.
P. 40 KEVIN
Bzzz.
No idea what this was about but I did giggle?
Did only Tully leave? I thought there was a group of people meeting them? It was explained like that in the action before?
Now I understand a bit more about the "Bzzz" comment, liked that line about the bee.
“damned school teacher.” Think this is supposed to be damn instead of damned?
P. 41 Think gang should be capped here? Could be wrong about that one.
P. 42 There is a line that looks wrong on this page?
In the
CENTER OF TOWN
Think this is an accident and should be together in the same sentence? Check it out.
I do like Fat Lucy’s description, very vivid but why do none of the new characters have ages?
P. 43 Sheriff not capped in Tully’s dialogue.
P. 45 “Kevin wades through the Crowd” Crowd doesn’t need to be capped on this page
P. 47 “Tell me where he is” Missing question mark. Then start the next line.
P. 49 INT. SURGEON'S OFFICE – LATER
Feel this should be doctor’s office. Also, you use “later” a lot in the slugs, try just day or night sometimes? Needs to be broken up IMO.
You certainly have some distinct character descriptions.
P 51. Another slug problem here IMO. “EXT. SHERIFF'S OFFICE – CONTINUOUS” I don’t believe this scene can be consider continuous as it wasn’t immediately after the previous scene.
He’s marching through the street? Thought he was outside the Sheriff office?
P. 52 “Adriana drags” Wonder if this is supposed to be digging? Reads strange when Kevin starts digging deeper soon after is all.
P. 53 “He climbs after it” This reads awkward.
P. 56 “The look Adriana gives says she's not buying it.” What look is that again? Oh yeah, the one the missus gives me all the time.
Have to ask when Kevin got a gun? That sprung up on me, maybe I missed it?
P. 58 “You're not getting religion on me” Think you mean religious here instead of religion in Jed’s dialogue.
Question:
“A SILHOUETTE peers through slits in the boarded windows. From
his perspective, this stranger can see Snake and his gang,
Jed in the midst of them.”
Would you not need a P.O.V shot here?
P. 59 “FATHER JAKE's rifle” Is this the Father Jack’s intro or the rifles? Seems strange because we only see the rifle here according to the action? Also the “s” on the end needs to be capped.
Is Father Jake now outside with them. His dialogue has changed from (O.S)?
P. 60 “INT. MONASTERY – CONTINUOUS” Now this is the proper use of continuous IMO. A lot of inconsistencies in the slugs throughout for me.
P. 61 Think you need a change of slug here or at least a mini slug when Father Jack and Jed go up the stairs.
P. 64 FATHER JAKE
Give me one of those guns.
JED
Get your own.
What happened to Father Jack’s rifle?
“Another BANG! as” “as” should be capped here after bang.
“Garrett sends another bullet ahead of him up the stairs.” Awkward to read. Basically, he shoots up the stairs.
P. 66 It’s hard to believe they could here Snake from their position.
“Snake and the boys burst through the door” Thought Snake was already in the monastery? It’s getting confusing now because Garret’s dialogue isn’t (O.S). Where is everyone? He’s above them on the stairs but with them as they burst through the doors?
P. 67 Liked Kevin being left behind by the horse here and chasing it. Very funny.
So Garret is downstairs now...that’s cleared up but when did he get there?
P. 68 “the cigar to a puddle of lamp oil.” Should it be “into” instead of “to”
P. 70 “What she doesn't see is Garrett, slipped away from the fiery
interior, leveling his pistol at her position.”
The start of this sentence is telling.
Also the whole sentence should be shortened to 4 lines max, less if possible.
P. 71 Like the Idea of introducing the real July Wilson, nice touch.
P. 74 “they are alone in the office.” Or “They’re alone in the office” reads smoother.
P. 77 KEVIN
Just a little more.. got it!
Only two periods in the ellipses here.
P. 78 A walled gate seems out of place for Mercy IMO, I thought it was a bad town?
P. 84 “All marshals as reasonable as you?” Think you’re missing a “wish” at the start of this line of dialogue.
Also have to say that I find it difficult to believe that July would go out unarmed, he seems too clever and a scammer to fall for this.
P. 85 “slamming that city gates closed.” Should it be “slams the city gates shut”
“Wood splinters and holes appear behind him as the gun tears into the gate.” Think it should be “bullets” instead of “gun” as in “Bullets tear into the gate”
P. 91 “Adriana hugs close to Jed” Surely this should just be “Adriana hugs Jed” No need for the "close to"
I liked this, felt Kevin’s ending was too brash, rushed but certainly got a kick out of the Old West. Thought there could be a bit more humour added into the mix but that’s a personal preference. I thought there was a few problems with the slugs and character intros but nothing that took me away from the read, apart from the notes of course. It’s a good tale and I’m happy I gave it a read, sorry again it took me so long between reads.
Hope this helps.
Good work and keep writing.
Steve.