The Haunted Tale of James O'Neil by Michel J. Duthin (michel) - Short, Gothic Horror - How open would you be to fulfilling a request by a stranger with no idea what you will encounter and might risk?  An 18 century military officer, James O'Neil, explores this offer as he unravels an unearthly tale to help someone he never met. Fate sometimes works in mysterious ways.   8 pages, 4 characters, PG Rating - pdf, format

This was a creepy little tale.  Fit the OWC parameters quite nicely.  You had ill-fated romance, a spooky mansion and a helpful ghost.  Wasn't all that original, and the characters seemed rather vanilla, but I did like most of it.

There was some awkward phrasing and typos throughout.  You used "envelop" instead of envelope a couple of times.  "This the same gate falling from its hinges." also read oddly.

I didn't get the woman(his mother) and her need to have her hair combed.  If there was a a deeper meaning to that, I missed it.  After the great set up by Alan that he would never enter that house again, I was kinda disappointed that the events weren't scarier once James got to the place.

But,  a nice twist having James get his hands on the will.  One question though, if the mansion was actually destroyed by fire years before, how was he able to walk into the room and get the papers?  Wouldn't everything have been burned up?  Anyway, this was a pretty good, atmospheric chiller.

I'm sorry, but again, less than a page in, and I'm out.  Too many things to go into.

Congrats on completing an entry for the October OWC!

Nice story and I liked James.
It seemed odd that Alan pretty much forced the request upon him, if he was a ghost then why the letter to the manservant? and was he lying about chasing around town and finding James through his servant, Unless I am missing something, these earlier set ups went un resolved later on.
The hair thing was alluding to the mother being mad perhaps?
Nice details and dialogue (not including any typos).

James seems to be quite the cranky fellow.
The servants seem to be getting the short of the stick a lot.
It has gothic flavors, the three year dead line was a chuckle.
I doubt you meant it that way, but the plainness of it struck me.
On page six, your slug reads: day, but the time is 12am. Mistake?
The set up was pretty clear, the plot meandered after that.
The house and the comb ghost seemed rather tepid a pay off.
Thanks for playing OWC.

Regards,
E.D.

Hello Ophelia,

A story with potential but a few issues. My comments are;

Not sure I like your log line for a starter - quite long
The Inn - why not name it?
First line could put some off when he dines, in an inn!
Alan's dialogue seems a tad long
With the set up I found it difficult that James would accept the request so lightly
In the house and outside I did find myself a bit lost

Has potential.

All the best.

There's a good story in here, I think you just need more than 1 week to write it.  It seems like you've got a flair for historical fiction, I suggest you expand all of the  backstories (for the dead people and the living people) and have fun with it, this could be a very entertaining feature length script.

Your logline should be shorter. Maybe you tried to explain too many things. Your story is not so bad though. Nice try....

I don't know...this one seemed to hint at the possibility of so much more.  In the beginning, this worked well for me on several levels.  The writing is crisp, I liked the characters - for the first 2/3rd it felt like a nice gothic ride into an old fashioned ghost story.  (Envelop spelling issue aside).  

It fell apart for me after James left the mansion.  I was expecting something more straightforward - this one twisted in ways that I didn't expect...and that weren't satisfying (at least to my tastes)  Alan felt too real of a character to be a ghost.  And James too solid of a personality to have a hidden past.  

If I had my druthers, I'd say to keep the story through the meeting - but change it from there to a different ending.  What, I'm not sure.  But you've got a great setup and characters...they deserve an equally interesting fate!

I echo what others have said about the logline. It’s too long.

This has some good storytelling. It’s not always clear what exactly is going on, though. For example, I thought the key was for the desk. It wasn’t until James’ exchange with the gardener that I knew it was for the door.

Some of the dialogue was really good. Occasionally, it was a bit cliché for movies of the period.

I thought the mad mother ghost was off the wall in a good way.

Overall, good job.


Breanne

I thought this was OK, a different twist to what I was expecting so I enjoyed that. Captured the mood reasonably well, although I think you need to tighten up some of it.
Quick read, well written in places, a little confusing in others.
Nice job,

Need to fix the James character when he arrives at the mansion. really out there.

Like the story but I think you should have a better beginning. Have him drunk and waking up to see Alan. Or something similar.

Also, proofread.

Hope this helps,
Gabe

Can't say i was fond of the writing here. Although, what you were aiming for was quite ambitious and could work very well with a re-write. The set-up is there, albeit a little clunky. When James got to the manor, the story started to faulter for me until the end where he reads the Will. Overall, a pretty good effort for an OWC.

James

I liked this.  Told a good story and had excellent use of the ghost.  There were a couple things that didn't quite come off right.  For example him brushing the girl's hair.  It just seemed peculiar that he would actually do it to some random girl walking around the place.  The other was how he found himself back at the mansion at the end.  Felt too convenient.  Need something else there, I think.  

But I did like this.  Good utilization of everything.  Some of the writing comes off awkwardly at times and there's uses of both present and past tense all over the place, so fix that up.  Otherwise a solid entry.  Good job.

Greg

I feel like there's a good story here, but I personally don't understand it.

Alan comes to James in the beginning saying,

>"Forgive me Sir, are you James O'Neil?"

From this, it would appear that James does not know nor ever has known Alan, but by this:

>JAMES
Who are you?

ALAN
My name is Alan. You used to know
my father, Lord Ashley.

*There seems to be a connection. James knew Alan's father.

By Alan's request, James is to go back to Alan's mansion, into his bedroom and recover two packages of letters and a roll of papers.

So James does so. When he gets there, he all of a sudden turns all grumpy like to the servant meeting him at the door and barges into the mansion, pushing the old guy aside.

Now James, upon entering the bedroom and settling at the desk to search for requested papers and letters, now meets with YOUNG WOMAN. This is the woman Alan had explained was his girlfriend who died of, "affections of the heart". I don't know what that is, but its implicit in her desire of beauty, (I think anyways, and her obsession with her hair) and that's not a problem for me, but...

As I carry on, I'll explain where I'm confused...

Whereupon James helps Young Woman with her troubled knotted hair, she snatches the comb from him and disappears through a door that--

Subsequently is discovered to be locked tight and unmovable by James.

This frightens James and he quickly high tails it out of there. He leaves the manor, gallops away on his horse and then...

We find him in his bedroom:

JAMES' MASTER BEDROOM - NIGHT

I have no idea where this bedroom might be by the slug and certainly, from the first scene, we don't know either because James was at THE INN. So, there's confusion here. Also, no description is given of said room. I have no real keen idea in my mind where his is or his surroundings rich or poor.

Then, he's at that inn again. It would seem that there's no one there. It's written that:

>no one comes in

But that doesn't tell me that no one is in there, although I wager to guess that he is, exclusively alone, at this point. If it's true, I would bring that out through his POV, having him looking around and taking that all in. Not just looking at his watch.

Ok, so now he winds up going back to the mansion and this time, it's almost the same, but this time

He sees a damaged building that was destroyed by fire. Out of the saddle pack he grabs the papers and the following appears to be the reveal:

>He walks back to his horse, opens the saddlebag, and takes the letters out.

>On everyone of them, the same feminine handwriting.

>They are all sent to Alan Ashley with an official stamp that announces: RETURN TO SENDER.

James frowns, puts the letters back into the saddlebag, and takes the roll of papers.

He unrolls it and starts to read.

This is a last will in favour of James Lloyd Ashley, son of Alan and Louise Ashley.

James notices a line where it’s written: “Because of his mother’s madness, little
James has to be left in Father Oliver’s care.“

***Now questions...

What is feminine handwriting? It says above that Alan and Louise Ashley are James' parents. If this is so, then James would have recognized Alan in the first scene as his father.

Also, seems to be referenced that James was willed The Manor by his parents, but there's also something about his mother's madness and being left in a dude named Father Oliver's care. I'm confused because of the "time element"...

When did James' father and mother die? It would seem that YOUNG WOMAN was his mother? Is she? If that is so, wouldn't he have recognized her? But I also thought that YOUNG WOMAN WAS Alan's (James' father's girlfriend). But that too has me confused because there was no "relationship" like that shown in the beginning.

The YOUNG WOMAN died due to "affections of the heart" it is described. A nice way of saying she went mad, but why? What caused her to go mad?

For me, I need the author to explain this one to me.

I feel this one needs to be reworked. There's a lot here that could be coaxed out of it.

Sandra