Print Topic

SimplyScripts Screenwriting Discussion Board  /  October '07 One Week Challenge  /  Baxter's Wish
Posted by: Don, October 8th, 2007, 10:19pm
Baxter's Wish by Patrick Michael - Short, Comedy - When two stoners discover a magical, talking pumpkin, they learn that the life of a pumpkin is never easy and the only way for one to achieve a proper death is to be baked into delicious pumpkin pies. < 12 pages - pdf, format 8)
Posted by: Don, October 9th, 2007, 10:25am; Reply: 1
Posted by: The boy who could fly, October 9th, 2007, 10:52am; Reply: 2
I thought that script was swell, quite swell indeed, it fit the genre and theme perfectly, also I think so far this is the only pumpkin bong script:D  Lars and Dweezle were kind of an updated cheech and chong, there banter with Baxter was quite amusing, quite amusing indeed.  "whip-its"  HAHAHA, I'm getting idea's here:P  Anyways good work on a job well done.  And like the song goes "a friend in need's a friend indeed, a friend with weed is better" ;D
Posted by: tomson (Guest), October 9th, 2007, 12:09pm; Reply: 3
I liked the idea here. Quite creative I thought.

The script itself is fine, but there's mostly just dialogue. The dialogue is fine btw, but I'd like to see a little bit of something going on too. Doesn't have to be much, but something to stimulate visually and not just through the dialogue.

I thought the idea was good, fairly humorous and written well. :-)
Posted by: CindyLKeller, October 9th, 2007, 12:51pm; Reply: 4
He talks like your Dad. LOL

Two stoners, a talking pumpkin, and a mission.

I thought this was a cute script that fit the challenge.

Good job,
Cindy
Posted by: dslah, October 9th, 2007, 5:03pm; Reply: 5
I didn't particularly like this one. It wasn't "bad" per se, just did suit my tastes.

The formatting and spelling was all done well (although I think you could've shortened some of the descriptions in the first few pages)

I felt that the "Mister Potato Pumpkin" conversation fell flat, but you had a good ending.

The highlight of the script for me were Baxter's final words.

The only thing that brought this script down to me was the story (or lack thereof), I couldn't find myself interested, especially in these "stoner" chracters. I've never been one for stoner humour so I didn't find much of their antics particularly funny.

A solid effort though. 6\10.
Posted by: Seth, October 9th, 2007, 9:38pm; Reply: 6
This was a quick read! Points for that. The idea of employing a pumpkin as a bong is, I think, very creative. The humor, though, didn't register with me. I would've liked to have seen Dweezil and Lars interact on an even more tripped-out level with Baxter.

Seth
Posted by: Takeshi (Guest), October 10th, 2007, 6:36am; Reply: 7
Lars? You're obviously a Metallica fan. The name Dweezle rings a bell too, but I can't quite place it, I'm thinking 70s metal for some reason.

This was an entertaining light comedy. I enjoyed Baxter's Mr Potato Head lecture and the, "He talks like your dad", response.  I also liked the way Lars laughed at Dweezel and said, "Owned", when Baxter set him straight about the Mr Potato Head body parts.

The ending was strong, and I'm guessing you're a teenager because it seemed like you were using contemporary stoner lingo instead of dated stoner lingo like dude and man.

I don't have any changes to suggest.

Posted by: Zombie Sean, October 10th, 2007, 7:21pm; Reply: 8
This one was good. I don't really have any complaints about it.

Except Baxter sort of rotted quickly, didn't he? Haha and then "Kill...me..." reminded me of Alien Resurrection when Ripley finds all her clones.

Nice job.

I like Pumpkin pie.

Sean
Posted by: James McClung, October 10th, 2007, 8:38pm; Reply: 9
I liked this one a lot. There's two other scripts involving a talking pumpkin but you managed to take this one in another direction. I liked Baxter. He was kind of a buzzkill but if I was a pumpkin and I saw my friend get turned into a pipe, I'd be pretty pissed myself. Plus he had an attitude, which I really liked, and he was really able to make himself stand out, sticking it to these guys. The exchange between Baxter and the stoners was pretty funny. Some of the one liners were a little on the cliche side but you knocked a couple out of the ball park as far as I'm concerned. In particular, kudos to the "whip-its" line. Dennis Leary comes to mind, who is one of my favorite comedians. The whole "anatomy of a pumpkin" concept, complete with seeds and "stems" wasn't as funny as it was clever. That is to say, it was funny but I was more impressed by the thought that must have gone into that. You had me wondering where his other parts were until the end. The end, I loved, as well. Maybe it felt a little tacked on but a rotting Baxter grunting "kill me, you idiots" was an amusing image.

I can't think of anything to complain about with this one. It worked well for me and for the most part seemed well thought out and certainly well written, despite a few dud stoner jokes. Good job.
Posted by: EBurke73, October 10th, 2007, 9:26pm; Reply: 10
I thought this had some funny lines.  Baxter made for a nice foil for the two stoners.

Not much of a story, though.  "Go plant seeds."  "Okay."  But the dialgue was nice, except the potato pumpkin thing ran a bit too long.

Kinda reminded me of the Dennis Leary bit where stoners think everything will make an excellent bong.

Really liked the ending.
Posted by: Blakkwolfe, October 11th, 2007, 3:58pm; Reply: 11
Doooode....that was...like, (cough, cough)...awwe some...Like...Like when they made the pumpkin, like, into, like, a bong...Then like the ...pototoe head pumpkin is all like...pissed and sh*t?...Doooode., that was like...(cough) wicked funny.

Just teasin.  I liked the short. I considered doing the talking pumpkin in mine, and I'm glad I didn't. Baxter was a great contrast having to deal with these two stoner dudes.

Liked the pumpkin anatomy lesson, although I felt terrible for Baxter at the end...poor guy! I'm sure with thier baking brownies expertise they might have been able to figure out how to make a "special" kind of pumpkin pie.

Good Job!

p.s. Might Dweezil be based on Dweezil Zappa?
Posted by: Mr.Ripley, October 11th, 2007, 4:53pm; Reply: 12
This reminds me of Bill and Ted, which in an odd was very funny. I like the new take of a Jack O'Lantern; it was bound to come. This was a world I'm interested to read about especially about the pie's part. :)

Gabe
Posted by: Sandra Elstree., October 14th, 2007, 4:15pm; Reply: 13
This was a good one, but you know what?  I actually felt sorry for Baxter at the end.  Well, you know I always cried for Bambi and I have a hard time with nature shows.

Marvelous though, I liked the bong idea and I think that this is a clean script.

I like the names you chose and I think you've succeeded with this in the way you really brought on the suspension of disbelief because Baxter just makes me think about how when I was a little girl, I actually did feel sorry for vegetables.  Really!  I think I was 3 years old.

Anyways, it's funny because these guys are getting stoned on weed and one of them figures it might be a "flashback" and that was a really good one:  "That's from acid."

I don't do drugs, but I myself joke at home when the cupboard doors are left open that I'm having a "flashback."  Simply because when I was a very little girl and Mom and Dad were having a hard time with money, we didn't have any cupboard doors on in the kitchen.

I don't know why, I guess they were taken off with the intention of new ones being put on, but for the longest time (it felt like my entire childhood) we didn't have kitchen cupboard doors.  Maybe it was so that if Mom or Dad got mad, they could easily reach in for dish to throw.

Anyways, I loved you work.

Good Job.

Sandra
Posted by: mcornetto (Guest), October 14th, 2007, 10:31pm; Reply: 14
I liked this one. It reminded me of growing up in the '70s. While I read this I was trying to remember whether or not we ever made a pumpkin bong.  It seemed like something we would have done. But I find a lot of those memories to be a bit of a blur.

Anyway, the concept and execution were well done. The character and dialogue were top-notch. But I did feel that Baxter got a bit preachy and I thought the script could use some editing because I felt some of the dialogue was superfluous.      
Posted by: Ian, October 16th, 2007, 4:12pm; Reply: 15
Someone already said this reads fast, and it really does! I guess that's because it's dialog heavy, which was fine in this case because the dialog was of a pretty good quality throughout. There were nice ideas in this one (pumpkin bong, pumpkin anatomy, pumpkin's believing that being carved or put in a pie is their destiny etc), and some funny lines ('that's acid, dick' and 'he talks like your dad' were my favourites). Good use of the the subject and funny at times. Cleanly written too.

I agree with those who said some parts fell flat, and it doesn't help that I'm not a huge fan of stoner comedy (but yours didn't seem too recycled which is good). I also felt that Baxter saying 'Well, you're stroking my penis' kinda killed the joke... I knew that's where it was going before he said that line, so when he actually spelled it out for us I was like 'Yeah, we got it...' and it ruined it a little.

Overall, a pretty good script that was faithful to the challenge objective and provided some giggles :)
Posted by: BryMo, October 16th, 2007, 4:31pm; Reply: 16
haha i liked this one a lot. Pretty quick for me to read. i liked a few of the lines these kids had. The "he talks like your dad" line made me chuckle. i also thought the ending was great. Great job. Enjoyed this one a lot.
Posted by: Hoody, October 24th, 2007, 6:57am; Reply: 17
First script I read out of the bunch.  Way to set the bar!

It was good.  There's not much I can say that hasn't already been said except that if shot right, Baxter's final lines could be one of the funniest things ever.

Good job.  I had fun reading it.
Print page generated: April 29th, 2024, 9:04pm